Carol | Strappy Stiletto Heels

Carol | Strappy Stiletto Heels

Black / 4
$89.95
Sale price  $89.95 Regular price  $160.00
Skip to product information
Carol | Strappy Stiletto Heels
★★★★★ 4.8 /5 | 2158+ reviews

Carol | Strappy Stiletto Heels

$160.00 $89.95 Save 43%
Free Shipping with USPS
30-Day Money-Back Guarantee
Loved by 150,000+ customers across the US
ColorBlack
Size
Low in stock, only a few left
Mastercard
Visa
American Express
Apple Pay
Google Pay
Diners Club
UPDATE: Due to high demand, only a limited quantity remains. If “Add to Cart” is available, the item is still in stock.

The heel that makes you feel like yourself again.

There is a version of you that walks into a room and owns it. The Carol was made for her.

A sleek black suede stiletto with delicate crossover ankle straps that wrap elegantly around the ankle — the kind of heel that makes a simple outfit look like a deliberate choice. Feminine without being fussy. Striking without trying too hard. And comfortable enough to wear from dinner to dancing without once thinking about your feet.

Why Women Choose the Carol | Elegant Heels
  • Crossover ankle strap for real security. Not just decorative. The adjustable wraparound strap holds your foot firmly and comfortably in place from the first hour to the last — no slipping, no adjusting, no thinking about your shoes when you should be thinking about the moment.
  • Cushioned insole for all-day comfort. Because elegance should never cost you your comfort. The Carol is lined with cushioning that supports your foot through extended wear — so you can stay present, stay confident, and stay in them all evening long.
  • Sleek pointed toe that lengthens the leg. A refined silhouette that flatters and elongates — the kind of line that makes every outfit look more considered and every entrance more memorable.
  • Slender stiletto heel with a stable base. Graceful height that feels more secure than it looks. The Carol gives you presence and poise without the instability that kept you away from heels in the first place.
  • Black suede that goes with everything. The most versatile heel in your wardrobe. Pairs beautifully with a midi dress, wide-leg trousers, or a classic little black dress — and elevates all of it effortlessly.

Made for women who want elegance without compromise — for any occasion.

 

Shipping & Delivery

Shipping - Shipping to the US takes 4-9 business days after your order is processed. Order processing usually takes 1-3 business days.

24/7 Customer Service

At Martha & Lily NY, we believe that caring for you goes far beyond the perfect fit, it’s the heart of who we are.

Whether you’re seeking sizing advice, tracking an order, or need assistance with a return, our friendly team is always here for you.

We treat every customer like family with patience, honesty, and attention to detail.

📩 We’d love to hear from you:

Reach us anytime at support@marthaandlily.com we’ll make sure your experience is as beautiful as your purchase.

Loved by 150,000+ Customers

More than 150,000 customers trust Martha & Lily with an average rating of 4.8 out of 5 stars. Your satisfaction and confidence mean everything to us.

Buy More, Save More

Buy 2

10%

Off

Buy 4

20%

Off

Buy 5+

25%

Off

Discounts apply automatically at checkout.

Mix & match across all collections.

Lisa | Orthopedic Heels

Lisa | Orthopedic Heels

Lisa | Orthopedic Heels

$89.95
Sale price  $89.95 Regular price  $140.00
Frances | Sophisticated Heels

Frances | Sophisticated Heels

Frances | Sophisticated Heels

$89.95
Sale price  $89.95 Regular price  $249.99
Mary | Orthopedic Heels

Mary | Orthopedic Heels

Mary | Orthopedic Heels

$89.95
Sale price  $89.95 Regular price  $120.00
Janet | Slim Pointed Patchwork Heels

Janet | Slim Pointed Patchwork Heels

Janet | Slim Pointed Patchwork Heels

$89.95
Sale price  $89.95 Regular price  $130.00
Cassie | Golden Summer Charm Heels

Cassie | Golden Summer Charm Heels

Cassie | Golden Summer Charm Heels

$89.95
Sale price  $89.95 Regular price  $140.00
Catherine | Modern Heels

Catherine | Modern Heels

Catherine | Modern Heels

$89.95
Sale price  $89.95 Regular price  $229.99
Dorothy | Buckle Strap Block Heel

Dorothy | Buckle Strap Block Heel

Dorothy | Buckle Strap Block Heel

$89.95
Sale price  $89.95 Regular price  $266.95
Susan | All-Day Comfort T-Strap Heels

Susan | All-Day Comfort T-Strap Heels

Susan | All-Day Comfort T-Strap Heels

$89.95
Sale price  $89.95 Regular price  $266.95

Reviews That Make Us Emotional

Trusted by 150,000+ customers ❤️
Customer review
Kayla P. ★★★★★

I danced, sat, ate, and hugged everyone comfortably. That is rare for a wedding dress at my age.

2 weeks ago
Customer review
Jessica W. ★★★★★

I got compliments from women half my age. That alone made my whole evening.

3 weeks ago
Customer review
Audrey T. ★★★★★

The fit made me feel polished without trying too hard. I looked like myself, just a little more confident.

4 days ago
Customer review
Jacky R. ★★★★★

I did not feel squeezed, exposed, or uncomfortable. I felt dressed up in the best possible way.

1 month ago
Customer review
Melissa L. ★★★★★

For the first time in years, I did not feel like fashion forgot me. This dress felt like it was chosen for women like me.

1 week ago
Customer review
Alicia S. ★★★★★

This dress did not fight my body. It sat softly, moved easily, and made me feel elegant again.

5 days ago
Customer review
Kayla P. ★★★★★

I danced, sat, ate, and hugged everyone comfortably. That is rare for a wedding dress at my age.

2 weeks ago
Customer review
Jessica W. ★★★★★

I got compliments from women half my age. That alone made my whole evening.

3 weeks ago
Customer review
Audrey T. ★★★★★

The fit made me feel polished without trying too hard. I looked like myself, just a little more confident.

4 days ago
Customer review
Jacky R. ★★★★★

I did not feel squeezed, exposed, or uncomfortable. I felt dressed up in the best possible way.

1 month ago
Customer review
Melissa L. ★★★★★

For the first time in years, I did not feel like fashion forgot me. This dress felt like it was chosen for women like me.

1 week ago
Customer review
Alicia S. ★★★★★

This dress did not fight my body. It sat softly, moved easily, and made me feel elegant again.

5 days ago
Customer review
Kayla P. ★★★★★

I danced, sat, ate, and hugged everyone comfortably. That is rare for a wedding dress at my age.

2 weeks ago
Customer review
Jessica W. ★★★★★

I got compliments from women half my age. That alone made my whole evening.

3 weeks ago
Customer review
Audrey T. ★★★★★

The fit made me feel polished without trying too hard. I looked like myself, just a little more confident.

4 days ago
Customer review
Jacky R. ★★★★★

I did not feel squeezed, exposed, or uncomfortable. I felt dressed up in the best possible way.

1 month ago
Customer review
Melissa L. ★★★★★

For the first time in years, I did not feel like fashion forgot me. This dress felt like it was chosen for women like me.

1 week ago
Customer review
Alicia S. ★★★★★

This dress did not fight my body. It sat softly, moved easily, and made me feel elegant again.

5 days ago

Buy More, Save More

Buy 2

10%

Off

Buy 4

20%

Off

Buy 5+

25%

Off

Discounts apply automatically at checkout.

Mix & match across all collections.

Alessia - Everyday Comfort Dress

Alessia - Everyday Comfort Dress

Alessia - Everyday Comfort Dress

$59.95
Sale price  $59.95 Regular price  $200.00
Grace - Timeless Vintage Dress

Grace - Timeless Vintage Dress

Grace - Timeless Vintage Dress

$59.95
Sale price  $59.95 Regular price  $200.00
Karin - Everyday Comfort Dress

Karin - Everyday Comfort Dress

Karin - Everyday Comfort Dress

$59.95
Sale price  $59.95 Regular price  $200.00
Esra - Everyday Comfort Dress

Esra - Everyday Comfort Dress

Esra - Everyday Comfort Dress

$59.95
Sale price  $59.95 Regular price  $200.00
Emily - Bohemian Dress

Emily - Bohemian Dress

Emily - Bohemian Dress

$59.95
Sale price  $59.95 Regular price  $200.00
Emma - Easygoing Comfort Dress

Emma - Easygoing Comfort Dress

Emma - Easygoing Comfort Dress

$59.95
Sale price  $59.95 Regular price  $200.00
Diva - Everyday Comfort Dress

Diva - Everyday Comfort Dress

Diva - Everyday Comfort Dress

$59.95
Sale price  $59.95 Regular price  $200.00
Dilara - Everyday Comfort Dress

Dilara - Everyday Comfort Dress

Dilara - Everyday Comfort Dress

$59.95
Sale price  $59.95 Regular price  $200.00

Buy More, Save More

Buy 2

10%

Off

Buy 4

20%

Off

Buy 5+

25%

Off

Discounts apply automatically at checkout.

Mix & match across all collections.

Where Comfort Meets Confidence

For too long, women have been made to feel like their bodies were the problem. At Martha & Lily, we believe the clothes were.

Every piece is chosen to flatter real bodies, move with real lives, and make you feel beautiful without asking you to change a thing.

FREE SHIPPING WITHIN THE U.S.

Free shipping on every order across the U.S. this week only. We’ll deliver straight to your door, safely and without extra cost.

30-DAY MONEY-BACK GUARANTEE

Shop with confidence. Every order comes with a 30-day money back guarantee, so you can try us risk-free.

24/7 CUSTOMER SERVICE

If you have any questions, feedback, or concerns about your order, don’t worry — you can always reach us at support@marthaandlilly.com. We’re here to help and happy to assist you.